My Vent on the Constant Cries of “Fake News”

In watching the CBS This Morning  news show and reading the  three  tweets posted in a current report, on the president’s recent tweeting, written, yesterday or today, by Mr. Trump where he again assaults media, calling them “fake news”. Again, I remembered the history, of one of the Hitler’s components of the lead up to the Holocaust and World War II being Hitler’s dismissal of all news sources. When he had discounted the news sources enough, they were no longer trusted by the people and their warnings of Hitler’s choices ending badly for races of people.

There are so many less than accurate (understatement) sources out there not to be trusted, when they are shared and spread like wildfire on social media. I, for one, have renewed my St. Louis Post-Dispatch newspaper subscription giving me access to Washington Post as well. As a ‘former’ reporter, I learned in Journalism 101, print news is about 89% more accurate than television or blogs. Since print articles are backed by heavy research and not fake. That is unless the interviewees are playing us. Be careful which sources you trust, but don’t believe all news is ‘fake news’.

© Nanette Traband
October 2017

Here is a little history lesson:

“The Establishment of a Totalitarian State”

When Hitler was appointed chancellor he called fresh elections for March. The SA began to attack their political enemies” [news reporters telling the truth] “especially the Communists and Social Democrats. Their papers were closed down their offices raided, their meetings attacked and their members beaten up.”

Quote compliments a paper on European History, “Hitler’s Rise to Power,” the Intellectual property of Dr. Marjorie Bloy and written by Stephen Tonge

Posted in Opinion | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Considerate Discussion on My Facebook Page, Please

I was online late last night (early this morning) and I always glance at my postings on my Facebook page to see if any discussion has ensued. It had and it disturbed me and further curried my wakefulness of the wee hours.

 

I love discussion and I long for more than often appears. When writing editorial/commentary, I knew I had accomplished my goal when I received feedback, whether agreement or disagreement. I had one gentleman whose opinions/views were always counter to mine and I loved the mutually considerate email exchanges we would have over various topics.  He would also send letters to the editor stating his opinion and position for that opinion and I welcomed seeing those on the same page of the paper as well.

 

That word considerate is the most important one in that previous paragraph and results in this essay and denouement request/rule.

 

This is my Page; I reserve the right to post anything that I desire, be it cutesy, informative, or controversial. I invite countering opinions, as long as they are Considerate counterpoint. I am entitled to my opinions just as you are entitled to yours. If I have research to back up my opinions, I will state that, and you are free to accept or reject it! This also goes for discussions among my friends. Consideration is expected overall.

 

Reacting to a comment can be passionate, but name-calling and taking offense  don’t belong. One of the many definitions of “take” is “to undertake; assume: to take on”. In a moment of enlightenment many years ago, I realized that I caused myself considerable stress and frustration by taking offense. The realization was the process involved is a verb; I had to read or hear something different from something I was passionate about and decide to act on it, to “take offense”. I was assuming that I was being attacked rather than another exercising their right to have a different opinion. To argue, call them names, or raise my voice closed my mind off to other ideas.

 

My dad always said, “It takes all kinds of people to make up this world.” He also said that opinions were like noses and everyone had one (I later heard it another way with a different part of the anatomy). He liked to engage in passionate discussions and I have been accused of truly being his daughter in the area of passionate writing and speaking. I “take” that as a compliment!

 

Back to “taking offense”: if you insist, take it private, where the other person is free to answer or ignore. It is more dignified than yelling (all caps) and name-calling (or assuming something written as being directed at you). Moreover, I would appreciate the courtesy.

 

Back and forth differing opinions are so welcome and I especially love when I can join in, but when someone has taken offense and lit the comments on fire, I avoid the conversation as I don’t want to have either friend take offense. I will, reluctantly, un-friend those who can’t abide my wishes.

 

I do put gory, controversial, or reprehensible  news items or articles on my page that should ignite discussion, but please no attacks or reaction to imagined attacks. It is my belief it is not personal it is discussion.  I know that all the comments are opinions and not aimed at me directly, rather directed at my opinions.

 

I have been attacked in the past (commentary/editorial), thankfully, privately. I have responded by deleting the emails and often not sharing what has happened. More often, it has been missives having nothing to do with Facebook and attacks are painful, especially posted, handwritten. I use to respond to such mail, now, simply, I TRY TO put it aside. As for the old adage to forgive and forget, in my experience,  it is easier to forgive than forget!

 

As you see, I am claiming my Facebook page as my page. I wouldn’t walk into your living room after being invited in (i.e. friended) and personally attack you. I would like the same courtesy.

 

In grade school, we learned the Golden Rule (well, my generation still did, by present activities, I am trying to determine if they still teach it). The most history I could learn about the origins of the phrase then was it was said (actually quoted) by Jesus in the Book of Matthew in the Holy Bible. However, the motto “Treat others as you would like to be treated” has had many incarnations since King Hammurabi wrote his code of laws for Babylon 15 to 16 centuries B.C. Many of his laws, as well as axioms like this one, are still assimilated into our own laws today, having survived approximately 3600 years.

 

If this little phrase has survived 36 centuries, I am declaring it the rule for my Facebook page, in my words:   Address each other here, as you would like them to address you.

 

It is simple and one. If you need to be ugly, you can follow another axiom I’ve heard, “If you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all.” or you can carry on in Private Message.

 

Thank you so much!

Posted in Essay, Facebook rebuttals, Considerate and Courtesy | Leave a comment

My Beloved Gatlinburg is Burning

By: Nanette Traband

When I was a kid, there were wonderful family vacations; I loved everything about what dad planned. I wrote an essay several years ago about how much I even loved getting lost as much as he did and the other three didn’t. We started vacationing when I was seven, the first being a trip with all six of us (eight including parents), ages six months to 19 years, to Buffalo, New York and Niagara Falls (American & Canadian Falls). Later trips were just five of us, the youngest three kids with mom and dad.

I can’t remember if I was nine or ten the first time Gatlinburg was the first destination of the two weeks.  In fact, it was at the end of the first day’s drive. Dad and mom had friends who had boasted repeatedly of Gatlinburg’s charms.

As an adult, Gatlinburg is on my way to and from South Carolina, it is a long drive from here, but it seemed longer as a kid. Dad was a big believer in not making reservations. It just didn’t occur to him that all the motels in any place could be full at the same time.

It was around five in the evening when we arrived in Gatlinburg. The No Vacancy signs didn’t deter him from stopping at each motel to inquire, some twice — hoping someone had cancelled. A couple of hours after we started looking at one of the repeat stops, a clerk/owner, having turned away many tourists, gave dad a tip she was giving to a few people only. She had a friend who owned a hunting lodge just up the mountain out of town a bit. He didn’t formally open for over a month, but he had his facility ready and was willing to take a few people.

I remember falling in love with the place the minute we entered, looking like Tara (the plantation from Gone with the Wind) from the outside and pine from stem to stern inside. From the paneling on the walls to the floors to the banisters, beautifully kept pine, the rooms, at least the two we had were similar to dorms with four twin beds in one and two in the one mom and I shared.

The rooms were in the back of the lodge, looking out over a pristine glen with a pond. In the dusk, there was a menagerie around the pond – rabbits, other small animals, a doe, and a buck. Dad wanted to go back into town and find some place to eat, but I wanted to stay on the window seat and look out. Dad won. We drove down the main street of Gatlinburg. In front of the windows of shops were crowds watching pizza dough being tossed, taffy being pulled, fudge being made, chocolates rolled, glass blown, etc.Once we finished dinner in a restaurant we found, we joined the crowds.

I am still drawn to little town windows, particularly pausing before pulling taffy and glass blowers. Over the past 30 years, since moving to South Carolina for two years, I have always made a point to include Gatlinburg in my route both up and back even if I only stop for half an hour or drive the now deserted road through the mountains on either side.

The last time I drove to South Carolina, I made a point of leaving early enough to spend about half a day in Gatlinburg on the way home. I wandered down the main street, but found it lacking many of those windows of my childhood, but it is more the mountains and rustic portions of Gatlinburg that I love. Over the years, I have distressed that I never knew the name of the lodge where we stayed (dad most likely said it and as a kid it didn’t register as important). Tonight as I look at the videos of flames engulfing buildings through wooded areas, I fear it is gone.

I am praying for the people of Gatlinburg who have been displaced or, at the worst, have lost everything, and as well as those in Pigeon Forge. I am also sad for the losses that will continue for some time to come, especially for those who lost their livelihoods/businesses as well!

Eastern Tennessee towns are pledging to help their sister communities of Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge to recover from the after the fires are out. Some places rise from the ashes even better.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Back to childhood and memories, I don’t Want

I fell down two basement steps this afternoon. My foot was too far on the edge of the step and I lost my balance (something I don’t have much of to begin with from a fall four years ago). I put my right “foot” down on the basement floor on the outside of my ankle first with emphasis on the outside of the side of my foot. My first instinct was to cry out in pain. The ex (landlord) was home for lunch (who doesn’t come home for lunch) and wanted to know what I had done now.

I got him to help me up, saying that if I could pull myself up on to it and then put weight on it walking then it was OK, right. Right? He said who knows. He pointed to my basement shoes as the cause of the fall, but I have been wearing them that way for eight years and never had a slip on the basement stairs before. He doesn’t say it in the same words, but it is obvious he thinks I do these things, still, to get attention, just like my mother said. It is then I remember why I got the divorce and curse my income situation and inability to move.

I may live here, but I am on my own. Unlike when I was a child, why would I keep getting hurt when I have no one to care for me. When I broke my leg four years ago, I had to sign up for Meals on Wheels in order to have at least one balanced meal a day.  Even when we were married, when I got hurt or had surgery, there was no “attention”. Why would I want all this pain with absolutely no “reward”!

I have been suffering with pneumonia for 11 days. Had it not been for my childhood friend Carol, I am not sure what I would have done. I couldn’t go to the store (luckily, my pharmacy delivers). Carol brought me broth, egg salad, pears, bananas, strawberries, kiwi, and cantaloupe (not to mention Boost); most of the fruit was already sliced so all I had to do was fix the meals. Being a Type II Diabetic, eating protein and fruit on a set schedule is key to the controlled state of my numbers. Beside the right foot, that now (almost 2000., fell around 1330, yeah, I like military time), there is a pain in my left leg about the place I broke the other leg four years ago.

There is a back-story to my spiral…

For my 12th birthday, 1967, I got a bicycle (grown up without the fifties fat tires of my older sister’s that I had been riding). Western Auto had a $10 fee for assembly, but dad fancied himself a handyman (whole other essay), and put it together himself. Sometimes, after a four-to-twelve shift, when he got home, he would fix steaks (not normal fare) in foil packets in the oven with chopped onions – I never have been able to replicate them – he had brought the bike in  from its hiding place in the garage, set it in the living room, and he was fixing some of those steaks.

Someone at work had brought him some beautiful beefsteak tomatoes. I snuck downstairs as he was slicing a couple. I was caught by mom seated on the end of the couch that was blocked from the upper landing of the staircase. It could have been the suppressed inhaled shriek at the bike with the bow and the card on it. She started yelling at me while dad came from the kitchen. He appealed to the premise that it was, in fact, already my birthday and he had an extra steak. I had to wait until morning on the card, but I loved the late night attention, steak, and the view of my shiny new blue bike (still my favorite color).

Almost two months later was the first day of seventh grade. I loved all my teachers and classes (except PE). I came home, changed clothes, and headed out on my bike. I rode every day unless it was raining. I was about a block from the house when I saw this tire going down the hill on Scott Street and wondered where it came from; as I looked behind me, I realized it was my front tire.  I hit the nut on the middle of the handlebars with my chin and then landed chin first on the asphalt with the rest of my body coming over my head the wrong way and thudding on the pavement.

I lay there stunned for a moment and got up running to the back porch of the house I had landed. It had been my best friend’s house until her family moved to Arizona that summer. I didn’t know the new people and though I explained, they would not let me use their phone. I remember sitting on their steps and sobbing when I noticed drops of blood falling on the step below me. I put my hand up and felt my chin bleeding and ran the half a block home and asked/begged mom to put a Band-Aid® on it.

She sat me at the hallway desk and had Steve fetch the hydrogen peroxide, Mercurochrome, and Band-Aids®, asking/ordering him to walk my bike and tire home from Scott Street. I continued my pleas for a simple cover on the wound (in my heart of hearts I knew it was worse than that, but wouldn’t consider such). As mom cleaned it, she kept clicking her tongue and telling me that it looked like it needed to be seen by the doctor.

The two to three weeks from stitches to removal and an actual Band-Aid®, were the longest weeks of my pre-teen life. Since the bike fell apart that one wasn’t my fault. At the last dress-out PE class of the school year, we were playing kickball in the gym. You kicked the ball from home, and tried to make it around the bases before the ball did. At first base, I was tripped (no one really believed me, but she admitted it to me at our 10-year high school reunion).

All I could see on the way down was the gym floor coming for my chin and I stuck out my arms. My right hand/wrist made contact with the floor first, bouncing across the floor in front of me as I fell the rest of the way down. The fall felt as though it was in slow motion and even the memory is the same. The nurse’s secretary was the only one there as the nurse was handling something in another part of the junior high. The secretary let me sit with an ice pack for a few minutes, then said, I was being dramatic, and sent me back to class with the ice pack. She said she would tell the nurse, but the nurse never did come to check on me. I was in pain and had never been in that kind of pain before. The teacher (last class of the day, the day before Memorial Day) checked it a couple of times. I had to take the ice pack back but just left it, as there was no one in the nurse’s office and I went home.

At home, mom agreed there was nothing wrong with it, I was being melodramatic, and told me to go out and play. I went outside, however, anything I tried to do (especially the trapeze) hurt like the dickens! Dad got home a couple of hours later and it had become swollen. He believed me and put ice on it. Back then, Memorial Day was still the 30th of May and was celebrated on that day no matter what day it fell on. The next day was Wednesday and since the doctor’s office was closed by the time dad got home, I would need to hold in there until Thursday.

The pain just kept building and it was the first time I had felt such pain; not even tonsillitis ever hurt that bad or the aftermath of the tonsillectomy. Ice cream couldn’t even help my wrist and dad was walking the floor with me all night, changing ice packs and keeping track of the next dose of baby aspirin I could take. I was wide-awake and crying, our doctor was on vacation, but I heard dad call the emergency room at the hospital (St. Joseph’s in Alton) in the middle of the night. There were no x-ray, or any other kind, technicians on at night and doctors were only called in for dire emergencies, which my wrist was not. They told him the orthopedic surgeon, Dr. Mira, held a cast clinic every weekday. Though it was a holiday he would have one that morning until noon. Dad told mother to take me the next morning.

We stopped off in Wood River for her to pick up her mother. I was scared, but since I was “being a baby and milking it for all it was worth” (didn’t know what that meant), I didn’t dare mention the scared part. A technician took me for an x-ray and returned me to the clinic waiting room. The wrist was not broken, but he explained to my mother the way I had landed on it, I had “studded it”, shoving the palm of my hand into the wrist each time, it hit. His remedy was to “half cast” it. He molded the bottom of a cast from the inside of my palm knuckles to just below my wrist. The cast (half) was only on the bottom of my arm forming a hard splint. He then wrapped it in an Ace® bandage holding the cast to the arm.

The trick, he told mother, was that he had braced the hand up slightly at the wrist. When he had turned my wrist up, it was almost instant relief. It still hurt, but not nearly like it had all night. I would spend the first six weeks of my summer in a “cast” and a sling (it would be off by vacation in August).

The next day was the last day of school and I had my first taste of operating with one arm – definitely no fun – even if I was still being told I was making it up (at home by one parent). Dad was off that next day also and he took me to school and went straight to the nurse’s office to give the secretary “a piece of my (his) mind”. I understand he was heard all the way to the office and got the attention of the principal as well. I overheard him tell my mother that the secretary was in a world of trouble.

In high school, I had quite a few knee mishaps (it was bone-on-bone and had to be replaced when I was 45). Each one was taken seriously by dad and my brothers but mom would tell me every chance she had me alone that I was melodramatic and making up the accidents to get attention. To this day, I am still not fond of pain. I have endured the same accusations with every accident or illness since childhood as well.

Today, when I fell down the basement steps, after he helped me up, the vibe I was getting that I had done it on purpose made me feel as though I am about three-inches tall and as unlovable as my mother always told me I was. Déjà´ vu!

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | 3 Comments

Reflections on Memorial Day

Reflection on Memorial Day

 

 “lest we forget…”

 

Rudyard Kipling

Recessional (poem)

 

 

Monday, May 26th is designated as Memorial Day this year. May 30th, is the actual Memorial Day, the holiday of my childhood. They may have made it a “Monday” holiday (no matter the date of the week) many years ago – along with others, e.g. Abraham Lincolnwas really born on the 16th of February, Thomas Jefferson on the 13th of February, and George Washington on the 22nd of February – but Monday holidays gave us fewer holidays (perk for employers) and created three-day weekends. In my mind, it created a means of forgetting intention of the holiday through the play and recreation focus of a long weekend.

 

Moving holidays from their actual date is a pet peeve of mine. I really didn’t think the Monday holiday idea would take when they did it. I didn’t think employees and states would stand for it. The Veterans were able to put up a tussle and kept their November 11 holiday intact. I was quite pleased. Maybe I am a one-woman show, but my efforts regarding Memorial Day feel futile, as if I am the only one who cares.

 

About 11 yearsago, I wrote an editorial/opinion column that ran in the local daily paper regarding the “real” Memorial Day. It was one that got overwhelming response and every comment included remarks intimating  this is one holiday, like the Fourth of July or Veterans’ Day that loses its meaning by being moved to a three-day weekend on the fourth Monday in May rather than the 30th.

 

I often belabor the point of my father’s bestowing on me the love of country, the cost of freedom, and the symbolism of the flag and its origins. My Memorial Day memories are why I believe the holiday belongs wherever the 30th falls:

 

I can remembe almost every Memorial Day as a child. Whether it was a year we helped Roy Wolfe put flags on soldier’s graves in cemeteries, the years we traveled, the Sunday before or after, to Calhoun County to my paternal great grandparents’ side to decorate graves (the grandmothers called it “Decoration Day”, its original name). Other years, we traveled to Southern Illinois to decorate the graves of mom’s relatives; either way, the actual day was a day of pause and reflection.

 

I remember it was usually the last or second to the last week of school and teachers hated the interruption. When Christmas or New Year’s Day falls in the middle of the week as well as Veterans’ Day and Thanksgiving Day, it is like there is a reverent peacefulness to the day for me. We came to a halt. That is what Memorial Day meant back in the day.You were faced with an interruption in the routine, planned ceremonies didn’t suffer from lack of attendance, and you remembered.

 

I realize the original intent for Memorial Day is fallen soldiers; I was raised to remember everyone who had touched my life as memory kept them a part of me. I don’t know if I could find that country cemetery again on my own, I do know I worry that those graves are lost in overgrowth. My dad’s ancestors on his father’s side are in a community cemetery in Lebanon with caretaker. His mother’s relatives in the country cemetery, every trip we would scythe grass, pull weeds, prune previously planted trees and flowers, and other general maintenance. I often feel guilty that I never learned directions when someone was alive to tell me; I was under 14 the last time I was there.

 

There is just atendency today to see “three-day weekend equal fun.” This holiday has become“Memorial Day weekend,” the kick-off to summer. The travel industry cleans upon three-day weekends, but where is the reverence and remembrance of the raisond’être which generated the holiday.

 

In the hustle and bustle of everyday news, the news is like an addendum, concerns get lost. A three-day vacation puts the meaning far in the background. Coming to a halt on the actual Memorial Day and remembering is the essence of this holiday. I remember this being a hallowed holiday and just as the veterans feared with Veterans’ Day, I believe the meaning of the human toll of the freedom won forus in the past wars isn’t given its weight with three-day holiday weekend. Roy Wolfe died several years ago. I mourned him for the mentor(s) he, and  his wife, had been all my life, but I especially mourn those who will never hear first hand accounts of the battles he was in, in the Pacific theater of World War II.

 

Over the years, I have sung solos at many a Memorial Day Remembrance Ceremonies in cemeteries or city parks. The past few years I haven’t been called for the little cemetery hidden amidst farmland where I was always invited to sing. The veterans/veteran spouses always joined veterans and spouses in the cemetery and the committee for the ceremonies dwindles more each year, as more and more of the veterans that planned them have passed. The man that always called on me, from my childhood church, can no longer drive. I miss the inclusion in that reverence. It is up to us to pass the meaning on!

 

Yes, “lest we forget…”

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Hello world!

Welcome to WordPress.com! This is your very first post. Click the Edit link to modify or delete it, or start a new post. If you like, use this post to tell readers why you started this blog and what you plan to do with it.

Happy blogging!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment